Image

3:53 PM / Wednesday February 8, 2023

29 Mar 2019

‘Divisive’ opening prayer given as first Muslim woman is sworn into Pennsylvania House

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
March 29, 2019 Category: Week In Review Posted by:

ABOVE PHOTO: Freshman rep. Stephanie borowicz, (r-clinton county) gives the opening prayer in the house chambers. (Screen grab photos: PA House of Rep.)

By Jan Murphy 

 [email protected]

pennlive.com

The opening prayer is often the least controversial part of the Pennsylvania House of Representatives’ ceremonial routine on a session day, but Monday’s prayer was different.

On the same day that the House swore in its first Muslim women member Rep. Movita Johnson-Harrell, (D-Philadelphia,) freshman Rep. Stephanie Borowicz, (R-Clinton County,) stepped to the House rostrum to offer a heartfelt prayer proclaiming her Christian beliefs and how the nation has forgotten Jesus and asking for forgiveness.

“Jesus, you are our only hope,” she said, before going on to pray for the House Republican leaders, Gov. Tom Wolf, and President Trump and for the president’s standing unequivocally beside Israel. But it wasn’t until the ending of her prayer when House Speaker Mike Turzai, (R-Allegheny County), appeared to reach out to seemingly cut her off.

“At the name of Jesus, every knee will bow and every tongue will confess Jesus, that you are Lord,” she said.

The prayer drew ire from House Minority Whip Jordan Harris, (D-Philadelphia), who accused Borowicz of weaponizing her religion to “intimidate, demean and degrade” the newly installed Muslim representative in front of her family, friends and guests who gathered to witness her take the oath of office.

House Minority Whip Jordan Harris, (D-Phila.) (Screen grab photos: PA House of Rep.)

“Let me be clear. I am a Christian. I spend my Sunday mornings in church worshiping and being thankful for all that I have,” Harris said in a statement. “But in no way does that mean I would flaunt my religion at those who worship differently than I do. There is no room in our Capitol building for actions such as this, and it’s incredibly disappointing that today’s opening prayer was so divisive.”

At the end of the session day, House Democratic Leader Frank Dermody of Allegheny County expressed his displeasure on the House floor about the prayer that quietly disturbed other members on both sides of the aisle. Saying for the 28 years he has served in the House, Dermody said he found the opening prayer represented a time where members paused to be inspired and united.

“It should bring us together and have us think about what we can do and how we can work together to make this state work,” Dermody said. “This morning on a very important day, on a day where we’re swearing in a new member, the first woman Muslim serving in the Pennsylvania House of Representatives in history, there was a prayer that was not meant to inspire us. There was a prayer that was not meant to bring us together.”

Turzai interrupted Dermody, admonishing him about ascribing motive to a member’s words. Dermody replied he was speaking about her words, not Borowicz herself.

“It was not meant to bring us together. It was not meant to inspire us. It was beneath the dignity of the House,” he said, drawing a full 20 seconds of applause from members.

An attempt to reach Borowicz after Monday’s session ended was unsuccessful.

He called on Turzai to appoint a committee to establish guidelines for the opening prayers.

Turzai shared that when the House formerly allows clergy to offer the prayer, they were asked to craft a prayer that was respectful of all religious beliefs, but that those instructions had not been submitted to House members offering prayer.

He reminded that the House currently is involved in a pending federal lawsuit over its refusal to allow nontheists — those who do not believe in a supreme deity — to be given the opportunity to offer an opening invocation at the start of House sessions. As a result, the House relies on its own members to offer the opening prayer on session days while the case is on appeal.

House Republican Leader Bryan Cutler, (R-Lancaster County), reacted to Dermody’s comment, encouraging members to be respectful of others’ beliefs and faiths.

  • Facebook
  • Twitter

Leave a Comment

Recent News

Local

City Commissioner Omar Sabir and community partners hold press conference kicking off Philly Rises tour

February 7, 2023

Tweet Share Pin Email City Commissioner Omar Sabir hosted a press conference to kick off the 2nd...

Entertainment

Philly Cultural Beat – February 2023

February 3, 2023

Tweet Share Pin Email ABOVE PHOTO: Gregory Porter (Photos courtesy: Philly Cultural Beat) By Steve Bryant February’s...

Go With The-Flo

Priceless will sing in the Roz Live musical tribute “GLADYS” at 54 Below in New York City

February 3, 2023

Tweet Share Pin Email ABOVE PHOTO: Priceless Photo courtesy:  Priceless By Flo Anthony Following her $24 million...

Oasis

cj speaks…  Waiting on the Lord

February 3, 2023

Tweet Share Pin Email No matter what is going on in your life, you rise to the...

Health

Are you ready to prioritize your health goals?

February 3, 2023

Tweet Share Pin Email Help protect yourself against pneumococcal pneumonia. BPT The beginning of a new year...

Food And Beverage

Gift decadence during this season of love

February 3, 2023

Tweet Share Pin Email FAMILY FEATURES Valentine’s Day may traditionally be a lovers’ holiday, but it’s also...

The Philadelphia Sunday Sun Staff