5:57 PM / Wednesday February 8, 2023

11 Dec 2020

The Electoral College: An Explainer

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
December 11, 2020 Category: Sun Report Posted by:

On Monday, the Electoral College meets to officially vote for the President of the United States. But does it still make sense?

By Denise Clay

Sure, Texas Attorney Gen. Ken Paxton has filed a lawsuit with the U.S. Supreme Court asking the court to invalidate the presidential election in four states — including Pennsylvania — that helped former Vice President Joe Biden win the presidential election back in November.

And sure, Texas Sen. Ted Cruz has been asked by President Donald Trump to argue the case in front of the court should the Supreme Court decide to entertain the disenfranchisement of millions of voters.

But despite the best efforts of a group of people who really ought to know better, the Electoral College, the group of people who actually get to elect the President of the United States, is going to meet on Monday and do just that.

For most of the republic’s existence, the Electoral College has been seen as something that we use, but don’t pay a lot of attention to. But in two of the last five election cycles, most notably 2000 and 2016, the person that the majority of Americans wanted to be president was denied the office due to the Electoral College.

So, let’s take a look at it.

Just what is the Electoral College?

If we’re honest with ourselves, the Electoral College was the Founding Fathers attempt to, well, idiot proof the presidency.

Established in Article II, Section 1 of the Constitution, the Electoral College was put in place officially to keep the voters in smaller states from being overruled by the larger states when it comes to picking the president.

Unofficially, it was the Founding Fathers way of making sure that the so-called uneducated masses didn’t pick the president directly. Heck, until the 17th Amendment was ratified in 1913, Senators weren’t elected via popular vote, according to our friends at the National Constitution Center. State Legislatures did that job.

The College, which meets every four years, has 538 Electors, and the number of electors each state is allotted is the same as it’s Congressional Delegation. The District of Columbia is given three, which brings us to 538. Pennsylvania has 20 electors and while some of them might be state legislators, none of them are federal elected officials. Under the law, federal officials aren’t allowed to be electors. 

State legislatures decide how these electors are chosen and the rules that govern them. Most states choose their electors and who gets them using a winner-take-all system while two states — Maine and Nebraska — use the District method, which hands out electors based on congressional district. In some states, electors are selected by the state’s political parties while in others, electors are voted on in the same way that elected officials are chosen, at the ballot box.

What will it be doing on Monday?

For at least two of Pennsylvania’s Electoral College members — State Reps Jordan Harris and Malcolm Kenyatta — the Electoral College meeting will be, literally, just another day at the office.

That’s because the Electoral College meets in the Pennsylvania House at noon on Monday. The state’s 20 electors, which include State Sen. Sharif Street, Attorney Gen. Josh Shapiro, City Councilmember Cindy Bass, and 2020 Auditor General candidate Nina Ahmad and Ryan Boyer, business manager for the Laborers District Council, will take his or her own ballot and vote. Electors are paid for their time.

The official copy of those ballots goes to the President of the Senate, or as we usually call him, Vice President Mike Pence. Secretary of State Kathy Boockvar, the National Archives and the presiding judge in the district where the electors are meeting — Chief Judge John E. Jones —- according to the National Conference of State Legislatures. Judge Jones’s ballot serves as a backup ballot should the official copy wind up lost or destroyed.

Considering the war that Republicans have been waging on the Electoral College, Chief Justice Jones’s copy may take on an outsized importance. A lawsuit filed by prominent Republican legislators designed to keep the Democratic electors from voting on Monday was just thrown out of court on Wednesday. 

Now the question always comes up of what happens if an elector decides that he or she doesn’t want to follow the will of the voters and cast his or her vote for someone else?

While the whole “faithless elector” thing doesn’t happen often — before the seven electors that did it in 2016, there hadn’t been a faithless elector since 1972 — it’s something that states have taken into consideration. Many states have passed laws regarding this and some of those states — Oklahoma, North Carolina, South Carolina, and New Mexico — there are punishments including fines and criminal penalties.

And we continue to elect a president this way….why?!

State Rep. Kenyatta was a high-profile surrogate for President-elect Joe Biden during the Presidential Election. He’s also a first-time Electoral College delegate, which means he’ll also be casting his vote for the former Vice President.

But while he’s happy that his signature will be in the National Archives and thinks Biden will make a good president, Kenyatta’s not crazy about the whole Electoral College thing.

“I have dueling emotions about this,” he said. “It’s an honor to be selected as an elector for President-elect Biden and to participate in this historic moment. I’m glad that my signature is going to be in the Library of Congress as a historic reminder of what we did to stand against [President] Trump and fascism. But I also think that it’s time to get rid of the Electoral College and move to a national popular vote.”

Kenyatta is not alone in that thinking. The 2000 Presidential Race between former Texas Gov. George W. Bush and former Vice President Al Gore and the 2016 Presidential Race between Trump and former Secretary of State Hillary Clinton were the most recent examples of what happens when the popular vote and the Electoral College vote don’t match.

Because removing the Electoral College outright would require a Constitutional Amendment, something that the smaller states the Electoral College was created to protect wouldn’t support, the states have been signing on to the National Popular Vote Compact. The states in this compact have pledged to give their electoral votes to the person who wins the national popular vote, not the state vote.

While New Jersey and Delaware have already signed on to the compact, Pennsylvania hasn’t. State Rep. Chris Rabb introduced the legislation that would put the state into it in 2017, but according to the National Popular Vote website, there’s been little movement on it since.

All of the Electoral College ballots must be received by the President of the Senate by Dec. 23. 

Congress meets in joint session to count the electoral votes on Jan. 6, 2021.

  • Facebook
  • Twitter

Leave a Comment

Recent News


City Commissioner Omar Sabir and community partners hold press conference kicking off Philly Rises tour

February 7, 2023

Tweet Share Pin Email City Commissioner Omar Sabir hosted a press conference to kick off the 2nd...


Philly Cultural Beat – February 2023

February 3, 2023

Tweet Share Pin Email ABOVE PHOTO: Gregory Porter (Photos courtesy: Philly Cultural Beat) By Steve Bryant February’s...

Go With The-Flo

Priceless will sing in the Roz Live musical tribute “GLADYS” at 54 Below in New York City

February 3, 2023

Tweet Share Pin Email ABOVE PHOTO: Priceless Photo courtesy:  Priceless By Flo Anthony Following her $24 million...


cj speaks…  Waiting on the Lord

February 3, 2023

Tweet Share Pin Email No matter what is going on in your life, you rise to the...


Are you ready to prioritize your health goals?

February 3, 2023

Tweet Share Pin Email Help protect yourself against pneumococcal pneumonia. BPT The beginning of a new year...

Food And Beverage

Gift decadence during this season of love

February 3, 2023

Tweet Share Pin Email FAMILY FEATURES Valentine’s Day may traditionally be a lovers’ holiday, but it’s also...

The Philadelphia Sunday Sun Staff