3:07 PM / Tuesday June 28, 2022

8 Nov 2019

Surprise! Surprise! Surprise!

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
November 8, 2019 Category: Local Posted by:

While much of election night in Philadelphia was formalizing the results of the May Primary, Working Families Party candidate Kendra Brooks shocked the world in the City Council At-Large race.

By Denise Clay

Since entering the City Council At-Large race after the May Primary, Working Families Party candidates Kendra Brooks and Nicolas O’Roarke had a mission: displacing the two Republicans —- David Oh and Al Taubenberger —- currently holding the body’s minority party seats.

Working Families In, Republicans Out, they said.

On Tuesday, the duo managed to accomplish half of that mission when Brooks became the first third-party candidate to win one of the minority party seats, defeating Republican Al Taubenberger. The other Republican at-large incumbent, David Oh, managed to keep his seat, besting O’Roarke and his Republican challengers: Dan Tinney, Bill Heeney and Matt Wolfe among others.

At a raucous Election Night celebration at Barbers Hall in North Philadelphia, Brooks and her supporters were jubilant about what they had just managed to accomplish.

“I have three words: We did it!,” she said. “Now let that sink in just a minute. Today, for the first time in seven decades, our city said ‘enough is enough!’ For the first time in seven decades, we broke the GOP. We beat the Democratic establishment, and we are bringing working class power to the City Council.”

“They said we couldn’t do it,” Brooks continued, “but we have shown them that we are bigger than them and that this is our moment.”

What made this year’s Council At-Large race one to watch was the number of independent and third-party candidates running for the offices. In addition to Brooks and O’Rourke, Sherrie Cohen, Maj Toure, Clarc King, Joe Cox, Steve Cherniavasky and write-in candidate Charlie Hill participated in the City Council at-large race either as third-party or independent candidates.

But the Working Families Party candidacies were the most concerning to the Democratic Committee. At an annual gathering at the Famous Fourth Street Deli in South Philadelphia, Micah Mahjoubian, policy director for Democratic State Sen. Sharif Street was wearing a “Vote Straight Democrat” button.

He felt it was a necessary message for people to get because gatherings of people with similar values, or political parties, are going to be important as the 2020 Elections approach, he said. By having a pair of candidates say, as Brooks and O’Roarke said during their campaign, that Democratic voters should vote for them and then those on their ticket, could have unintended consequences, Mahjoubian said.

“We need to keep what happened in 2016 from happening,” he said, referring to the part third parties are assumed to have played in the Donald Trump’s presidential win. “The money that the Working Families Party spent to get rid of these two Republicans who don’t ever stop anything would have been better spent turning purple districts blue or red districts blue. Also, we have judges on the ballot. If  Democrats vote for the Working Families candidates, and don’t go back to the judges, we are going to have real Republicans elected that will do real harm to Philadelphians.”

Working Families Party candidates Nicolas O”Roarke and Kendra Brooks wait to speak at their Election Night party at Barbers Hall in North Philadelphia. Brooks made history by becoming the first third-party candidate to claim one of the charter mandated seats set aside for minority parties in Tuesday’s elections.

There was also a fear among Democrats that the Working Families candidates would wind up costing two At-Large democrats their seats. When asked about this at the Working Families Election Night party, District Attorney Larry Krasner said that was highly unlikely.

“I don’t think the math for that works,” he said. “There are seven Democrats for every Republican here in Philadelphia. These people represent the more progressive wing of the Democratic Party. They should have been supporting them and doing this 20 years ago.”

In the end, Krasner appeared to be right. All of the Democrats on the ballot for at-large bids won on Tuesday. In addition to incumbents Helen Gym, Allan Domb, and Derek Green, Isaiah Thomas and Katherine Gilmore-Richardson won their races. Thomas and Gilmore-Richardson will replace retiring Councilpersons Blondell Reynolds Brown and William Greenlee. Gilmore-Richardson served as chief of staff in Reynolds Brown’s office. 

Thomas and Gilmore-Richardson, Council’s first two millennials, will help bring down the median age of one of the nation’s oldest legislative bodies.


Helping them in that mission will be Jamie Gauthier, who officially became the new Councilwoman for the Third District. Gauthier defeated Jannie Blackwell for the seat in the May Primary, and will be the first person not named Blackwell to hold that seat in more than 40 years.

All of the District Council people up for re-election —- Mark Squilla, Kenyatta Johnson, Curtis Jones, Maria Quinones-Sanchez, Cindy Bass, Cherelle Parker, and Republican Brian O’Neill —- retained their seats. Councilman Bobby Henon also won, despite having a federal indictment that will likely go to trial in the new year.

There’s a new Sheriff in town now that Rochelle Bilal has been officially elected to the post. She replaces outgoing Sheriff Jewell Williams, who she defeated in the May primary when he couldn’t overcome a cloud of sexual harassment charges hanging over his head.

Tracy Gordon becomes the new Register of Wills. She defeated longtime officeholder Ronald Donatucci in the May primary to win the seat. 

And Omar Sabir joins Lisa Deeley and Al Schmidt as a City Commissioner, thanks to his win on Tuesday.

In what was a surprise to no one, Mayor Jim Kenney won a second term in the city’s highest office, defeating Republican Billy Ciancagilini in an election where Kenney refused to even acknowledge his opponent’s existence.

Several judicial races were also decided on Tuesday. Democrat Daniel McCaffrey and Republican Megan McCarthy King were elected to the State Superior Court. They will join Justices Anne Lazarus and Judy Olson, who won their retention bids on Tuesday. 

Justices Patricia McCullough, and Kevin Brobson won their retention bids for Commonwealth Court and Daniel Anders, Ida Chen, Robert Coleman Richard Gordon, Karen Shreeves-Johns, Diane Thompson, Sheila Woods-Skipper, Donna Woelpper, Glynnis Hill, and Roxanne Covington won their retention bids for the Court of Common Pleas and will be joined by Jennifer Schultz, Anthony Kyriakakis, Joshua Roberts, Tiffany Palmer, James Crumlish, Carmella Jacquinto, and Crystal Powell after their wins on Tuesday. 

David Conroy won in his bid to join Martin Coleman, Jackie Frazier-Lyde, Henry Lewandoski, Wendy Lynn Pei and T. Francis Shields on the Philadelphia Municipal Court. 

  • Facebook
  • Twitter

Leave a Comment

Recent News


Biden signs landmark gun measure, says ‘lives will be saved’

June 25, 2022

Tweet Share Pin Email By Bill Weissert WASHINGTON (AP) — President Joe Biden on Saturday signed the...


Guest Commentary
Solutions, not excuses; People are dying every day

June 25, 2022



Community College of Philadelphia to pay off $1.4 million in outstanding student account balances

June 17, 2022

Tweet Share Pin Email Community College of Philadelphia announced that it will pay off more than $1.4...

Color Of Money

Americans still have financial goals, just not sure how they will reach them

June 24, 2022

Tweet Share Pin Email BPT If you have a vision for where you’d like to be financially...


Takeaways: Trump’s mind ‘made up’ on fraud ahead of Jan. 6

June 17, 2022

Tweet Share Pin Email ABOVE PHOTO: A video exhibit plays as the House select committee investigating the...

Go With The-Flo

Sherri Shepherd’s talk show, “Sherri,” to air in place of former “The Wendy Williams Show”

June 17, 2022

Tweet Share Pin Email ABOVE PHOTO: Sherri Shepherd (Photo: s_bukley / Shutterstock) By Flo Anthony After 13...

The Philadelphia Sunday Sun Staff