3:09 PM / Tuesday June 2, 2020

23 May 2019

Philadelphia selects new Commissioners, Judges and Register of Wills in spirited primary election

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
May 23, 2019 Category: Local Posted by:

ABOVE PHOTO: Tracey Gordon and Omar Sabir

By Amy V. Simmons

Although the weather was flawless, the tradition of low voter turnout in Philadelphia’s primary election stood unchallenged.

In fact, numbers were on par or only slightly down compared to primary years, although anecdotally, they seemed much lower to individual voters as they scanned many nearly empty polling places, or were surprised to learn how many of their neighbors had not voted. 

Others blamed the closed primary system, although independents were allowed to vote on the ballot questions.

In a primary election that boasted one of the largest slate of local candidates in four decades, those who did vote, took slightly longer in the voting booth to make their selections.

Four local races — for CIty Commissioner, Court of Common Pleas Judge, Municipal Judge, and Register of Wills —  as well as one statewide race for Superior Court Judge, were among the several contests decided on Tuesday.   

City Commissioner

Three candidates bested 10 others in one of the largest slate of candidates for the office of City Commissioner in Philadelphia’s history. 

From one commissioner — Anthony Clark, who was AWOL throughout his tenure and does not vote — to the controversial procurement process of the ExpressVote XL voting machines, the office has recently been under intense scrutiny.

In spite of this, two incumbents — Democrat  Lisa Deeley and Republican Al Schmidt (who ran unopposed) — won the race handily.

Grassroots activist Omar Sabir emerged from the slate of highly qualified candidates to win the third seat with the highest percentage of the vote — 24.51%, over 70,000 voters.

Voting rights attorney and advocate Khalil Williams — who received an impressive 16.65% of the total vote, over 48,000 votes — was philosophical in a statement he posted to his Facebook page as he thanked his supporters and vowed to continue fighting for the issues he ran on.

 “We’ll continue to push the office for a robust election protection strategy in 2020 and beyond, for committed advocacy for election reform at the state level, for better civics education in our schools, and much more,” he wrote.


Court of Common Pleas

James Crumlish, Carmella Jacquinto, Anthony Kyriakakis, Tiffany Palmer, Joshua Roberts and Jennifer Schultz bested 19 other candidates in one of the office’s youngest and most diverse group of candidates to date. Beth Grossman, who ran on both tickets, won the Republican race.

“To both Democrats and Republicans who voted for me, I cannot thank you enough for the privilege of your votes. (Proud of the 23,000+ Democratic votes for a Republican candidate!),” Grossman posted on her official Facebook page. “Although I did not get on the Democratic ballot for the general election, I will be on the Republican ballot in November. Looking forward to meeting Democrats, Republicans and Independents on the campaign trail.”

Municipal Judge 

David Conroy bested Theresa Brunson — who finished strong, garnering 44.46% or nearly 67,000 votes in the race for Municipal Court Judge.

Brunson spoke about the experience and some of her concerns about the process in a Facebook post thanking her supporters.

“Although I received more than 66,000 votes, it was not enough to win a seat on the Municipal Court,” Brunson wrote. “Thank you to everyone who supported me, prayed for me and gave me advice on this journey. I have learned a lot, met a lot of good people and saw the ugly truth about some others. No African Americans were elected as Judges in Philadelphia yesterday. I vow to do all I can to expose and remove the bias in this system that causes this phenomenon. The struggle continues…”

Register of Wills

Tracey Gordon — who ran on a platform which included improving the efficiency of the generational wealth transfer process, increasing public education efforts regarding the office and the importance of making a will — bested long-time incumbent Ron Donatucci,  making history as the first African American and woman elected to the office.

“We overcame, and took out a 40-year incumbent,” she told supporters during a Facebook Live session. “ It is a new day in Philadelphia. I promise, as the new Register of Wills, that change is coming.”

Pittsburgh’s Amanda Green-Hawkins, an attorney for the United Steelworkers Union and Philadelphia Court of Common Pleas Judge Daniel McCaffrey bested civil litigation lawyer Beth Tarasi in the Democratic race.

Republican Party endorsed candidates Chester County Deputy District Attorney Megan McCarthy King — who also received an endorsement from President Donald Trump — and Cumberland County Judge Christylee Peck, bested former Montour County District Attorney Rebecca Warren. 

“There’s nothing more important than meeting voters face-to-face—nothing more valuable,” King wrote on her official campaign Facebook page. “I look forward to meeting more of you and continuing to gain your confidence as I seek a seat on the Superior Court. Together, with my running-mate, Judge Christylee Peck, we’ll travel far and wide to your counties and look forward to this next chapter of our campaign.”

  • Facebook
  • Twitter

Leave a Comment

Recent News


Risks complicate reopenings as WHO warns 1st wave not over

May 29, 2020

Tweet Share Pin Email ABOVE PHOTO: In this image provided by the New York Stock Exchange, New...


In a recent inter-continental video conference, Ghanaian and U.S. leaders are named to the board of The Collaboration for IT and Communications Excellence

May 29, 2020

Tweet Share Pin Email A group of business, professional, academic, civic and public-sector leaders from Northern and...

Go With The-Flo

Meghan The Stallion has partnered with Rihanna’s Savage X Fenty line for its summer campaign

May 29, 2020

Tweet Share Pin Email ABOVE PHOTO: Meghan The Stallion (Photo: lev radin / Shutterstock) By Florence Anthony...

Week In Review

11-year-old girl says racism behind white woman’s assault

May 29, 2020

Tweet Share Pin Email ABOVE PHOTO: This photo provided by Attorney Justin T. Bamberg shows Skhylur Davis....

Sun Report

The Very First Memorial Day

May 29, 2020

Tweet Share Pin Email The tradition of Memorial Day began on May 1, 1865, in Charleston, South...


Malcolm Jenkins to deliver commencement address for School District of Philadelphia’s virtual graduation ceremony

May 29, 2020

Tweet Share Pin Email The two-time Super Bowl champion will share words of wisdom during special event...

The Philadelphia Sunday Sun Staff