8:29 AM / Wednesday June 29, 2022

25 Oct 2014

Court is In Session

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
October 25, 2014 Category: Local Posted by:

ABOVE PHOTO:  Hundreds protest the School Reform Commission decision changing the teachers’ health care benefits last week.  (Photo by Leona G. Dixon)

The Philadelphia Federation of Teachers fired its first shots at the School Reform Commission in the Court of Common Pleas. They hit their target, if only temporarily. 

By Denise Clay

On Monday, Common Pleas Court Judge Nina Wright Padilla issued an injunction against the SRC that stops the body from making changes to the teacher’s health care benefits.

The changes, changes that included a requirement that teachers pay anywhere from $20 to $200 a month in health care premiums, had been imposed when the SRC voted on Oct. 6 to cancel the teacher’s contract. 

Jerry Jordan, president of the Philadelphia Federation of Teachers, praised Judge Padilla’s decision.


“The preliminary injunction granted today by Common Pleas Court Judge Nina Wright Padilla reinforces our view that, the School Reform Commission cannot simply decide to stop negotiating, then unilaterally cancel the PFT contract and impose new terms,” Jordan said. “The decision is a testament to the notion that these kinds of contract changes should be decided at the bargaining table.” 

Monday’s action is part of a series of legal challenges filed in response to the SRC’s decision to go to Commonwealth Court to get retroactive permission to cancel the PFT contract. In addition to asking that the entire case be moved to Common Pleas Court, the PFT has filed a complaint with the Pennsylvania Labor Relations Board accusing the SRC of bargaining in bad faith. 

“We feel that the SRC’s attack was not only cowardly and disrespectful, but lacking legal merit,” Jordan said. 

Monday’s decision was just the latest part of the shock wave that the SRC’s decision to cancel the PFT contract set off. From a rally that attracted thousands of people and led to the closing off of a section of North Broad Street to a contentious SRC meeting that featured 60 registered speakers and was peppered with outbursts from the audience, people have made sure that the SRC knows how they feel.

For example, during a presentation for Parent Appreciation Month, audience members shouted, “You don’t appreciate parents!” A presentation for the Home Depot Seniors of the Month was met with “Better make sure that the check doesn’t bounce!”

Then there were the chants of “What do we want?! Fair funding! When do we want it?! Now!!!” that seemed to break out, and the accusations on the part of teachers that the SRC’s decision was part of a plan launched by Gov. Tom Corbett and SRC Chair Green to save both of their jobs.

And that was just the unofficial comments. Those who signed up to speak to the SRC weren’t much nicer.

“We are not indentured servants,” Jordan told the board. “It is an absolute lie for the SRC to say that we weren’t willing to negotiate about health care and weren’t willing to share in the district’s sacrifice.”

“When you voided the contract with the teachers, you voided the contract with the community,” said Jesse Epps, a former sanitation worker in Memphis who marched with the Rev. Dr. Martin Luther King. “Families and children are calling on you to reconsider your actions.”

Even the students got involved.

“Our teachers deserve the right to a fair contract,” said Alfredo Practico of Masterman Middle School. “Our teachers, through the toughest of times, stood tall for our benefit. It’s been taught to us that it’s not whether you win or lose, it’s how you play the game. What are you showing us now?”

After the meeting, Hite and Green were asked if a contract settlement was still possible considering the bad blood between the SRC and the PFT. 

Hite was optimistic. 

 “At the end of the day, regardless of what happens in the courts, a negotiated settlement is better,” he said. “The teachers would rather have that.”

  • Facebook
  • Twitter

Leave a Comment

Recent News


Testimony: Trump fought security official for control of the presidential SUV on Jan. 6, demanded to be taken the Capitol as the insurrection began

June 28, 2022

Tweet Share Pin Email WASHINGTON (AP) — Donald Trump rebuffed his own security’s warnings about armed protesters...


Guest Commentary
Solutions, not excuses; People are dying every day

June 25, 2022



Community College of Philadelphia to pay off $1.4 million in outstanding student account balances

June 17, 2022

Tweet Share Pin Email Community College of Philadelphia announced that it will pay off more than $1.4...

Color Of Money

Americans still have financial goals, just not sure how they will reach them

June 24, 2022

Tweet Share Pin Email BPT If you have a vision for where you’d like to be financially...


Takeaways: Trump’s mind ‘made up’ on fraud ahead of Jan. 6

June 17, 2022

Tweet Share Pin Email ABOVE PHOTO: A video exhibit plays as the House select committee investigating the...

Go With The-Flo

Sherri Shepherd’s talk show, “Sherri,” to air in place of former “The Wendy Williams Show”

June 17, 2022

Tweet Share Pin Email ABOVE PHOTO: Sherri Shepherd (Photo: s_bukley / Shutterstock) By Flo Anthony After 13...

The Philadelphia Sunday Sun Staff