11:34 AM / Friday March 24, 2023

1 Sep 2017

Guest Editorial: On race and place, Philadelphia must play by the rules

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
September 1, 2017 Category: Commentary Posted by:

ABOVE CARTOON:  John Cole, The Scranton Times-Tribune


By Brett Mandel

Like each of us, cities earn their nicknames and, like each of us, cities may long for another nickname when saddled with a less-than-favorable one.  In a city with a mayor who just released a two-decade plan to be litter-free, Philadelphia may wish to be “The City That Works” but is still, mournfully, “Philthydelphia.” If it is to work, Philadelphia cannot be a city of the little fix because when the fix is in for some, the rest of us are left in a city that can never live up to its potential.

Two fundamental ways Philadelphia simply doesn’t work today have emerged as flash points.  One that is race-based and one that is place-based.

Because of city government action and inaction, there exist different sets of rules in Philadelphia for different races and different places.  Because of the choices made by the men and women who run our city, some people and some neighborhoods are treated differently than others.

Some Philadelphians may fear for their lives when interacting with law-enforcement officials.  Some Philadelphians may be shut out of employment opportunities when seeking to join the workforce building tomorrow’s Philadelphia.  Some Philadelphia neighborhoods are clean while others are not.  Some Philadelphia neighborhoods benefit from rational law and code enforcement while others endure look-the-other-way oversight that endangers lives and stunts rational development.

In recent weeks, activists with the organization Black Lives Matter have confronted elected officials to demand justice for a Black man who was shot in the back and killed by a Philadelphia police officer.  Their impolite but important disruptions have called attention to the fact that too many Philadelphia citizens believe their lives are of no consequence to others. 

Activists with the organization 5th Square support urbanist and sustainable transportation, land-use, and public-space policies.  They have specifically led a charge to rationalize the city’s response to illegal parking in the median of South Broad Street.  Their impolitic but imperative actions have highlighted the fact that the rules of our city are applied differently in different areas, demonstrating that some neighborhoods are valued while others fester and that some neighbors are able to cut corners and break the rules while others are punished for a single step out of line.

Here’s what both groups should understand:  they are waging the same war.   

If the place-based rabble rousers and race-based provocateurs recognize that they are fighting the same fight — trying to create a city with one set or rules — they could create a movement to make real and lasting progress.

Why are some Philadelphians shut out of jobs with building-trades unions?  Why are some Philadelphians more likely to fear encounters with law-enforcement officials?  Because Philadelphia politicians have not acted to make real change.

Why are parking laws and building codes rigorously enforced in some neighborhoods, but not others?  Why are dangerous conditions allowed to persist in certain parts of the city?  Because Philadelphia elected officials have allowed these conditions to persist.

In 2018, Philadelphia will elect state legislators as well as the committee people who serve as local political party representatives.  In 2019, Philadelphia will elect city council members and a mayor.  If the place-based activists and race-based activists can mobilize behind a platform of creating a city with one set of rules that actually works for all of its citizens and all of its neighborhoods, Philadelphia could be fundamentally transformed.

I’m happy to host the gathering and to buy the first round to get the conversation going.  Let’s just make sure to talk about a better city nickname for when we remake Philadelphia into the city we know it should be.

About Brett Mandel

Until recently, I was the Executive Director of the National Education Technology Funding Corporation (Eddie Tech), a private, non-profit organization working to help local public school districts utilize federal mechanisms to access more cost-effective financing for school construction and renovation.  Previously, I was Executive Director of Philadelphia Forward, a citizens’ organization promoting tax, government, and ethics reform.  Philadelphia Forward was instrumental in shaping public policy to improve tax fairness, reduce wage and business taxes, and enact ethics reforms.  I served on the Tax Reform Commission in 2003 and was director of financial and policy analysis under former City Controller Jonathan Saidel. I have written two books on baseball and one book on Philadelphia government.  A lifelong Philadelphian, product of our public schools (a Northeast High graduate), and public school parent, I grew up in Northeast Philadelphia.  I live in the Fitler Square neighborhood with my wife and three young children.

  • Facebook
  • Twitter

Leave a Comment

Recent News


Pennsylvania school allies criticize Shapiro’s budget plan

March 17, 2023

Tweet Share Pin Email ABOVE PHOTO: Students get on to one of several buses provided by SEPTA...


Hamilton Family Charitable Trust announces multi-year $1.5 million investment in Children’s Scholarship Fund Philadelphia

March 17, 2023

Tweet Share Pin Email The Hamilton Family Charitable Trust (“the Trust”) announced a $1.5 million investment in...


List of 2023 Oscar winners

March 17, 2023

Tweet Share Pin Email ASSOCIATED PRESS LOS ANGELES — Oscar winners announced Sunday: Best picture: “Everything Everywhere...


How the last banking tumult fuels today’s populist politics

March 17, 2023

Tweet Share Pin Email ABOVE PHOTO: FDIC member Dedra Dorn distributes “frequently asked questions” hand outs to...


Like his mother 23 years before, Justin Edwards is named most valuable player in Public League title game

March 18, 2023

Tweet Share Pin Email By Napoleon F. Kingcade PHOTOS COURTESY: Imhotep Charter ABOVE PHOTO: Imhotep Charter Panthers...

Go With The-Flo

Lenny Kravitz will host the 2023 iHeart Radio Music Awards

March 17, 2023

Tweet Share Pin Email ABOVE PHOTO: Lenny Kravitz (Photo: By Flo Anthony Oprah Winfrey recently increased...

The Philadelphia Sunday Sun Staff