6:42 PM / Friday December 1, 2023

20 Dec 2014

A misguided appeal for neutrality

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
December 20, 2014 Category: Commentary Posted by:

ABOVE PHOTO: Bill Cosby (Randy Miramontez /

By Karen E. Quinones Miller

This whole Bill Cosby situation has me remembering when witnessed a one-car accident in the Chestnut Hill section of Philadelphia back in 1993. 

I was the first one on the scene and helped a well-dressed African American woman out of the car–she had run into a lamppost. 

She clung to me for a moment, and since she didn’t seem hurt, I asked if she needed to use my cell phone. Before she could answer, a group of concerned white people came rushing over to assist, and the African American woman pushed me away so hard and fast I almost fell as she rushed to meet them. 

A little hurt, but much more befuddled, I got back in my car and watched the unfolding scene. 

The group momentarily crowded around her, breathing concern and offers of assistance, but as they realized what I had already ascertained — that the woman was drunk — they slowly peeled away until she was alone. 

She then staggered over to my car, and I let her in, once again offering my phone so she could call for help. After she called her husband, she said she didn’t want to “bad talk white folks,” but my not abandoning her proved that Black people know how to stick together. 

I was so pissed I could have hit her. 

Instead, I told her I had to leave so she’d have to wait outside for her husband and the tow truck. 

It gave me great satisfaction that just as I pulled away it started to pour down rain. 

A couple of years later, when O. J. Simpson was acquitted of killing his wife and Ron Goldman, I remembered that woman and that incident. 

And now, as Bill Cosby makes his appeal to the “Black media,” I’m remembering it again.

I think it is interesting that Cosby has asked the Black media to stay “neutral” regarding the sexual abuse allegations being made against him. Not objective. Neutral.

There is a big difference between neutral and objective. As a wordsmith, I know the difference…and I’m sure Bill Cosby does, too.

During World War II, Switzerland remained neutral. They didn’t join either the Allied or the Axis forces. They didn’t want to choose sides. They wanted to stay out of it; to stay neutral. 

Even when the human atrocities being committed by Hitler and the Nazis came to light, the Swiss continued to be their banker and their vault. In fact, after the war many Jews had to appeal to the Swiss government for the return of their artwork, heirlooms, and personal treasure. 

So, really, the Swiss actually profited from their neutrality. 

To be a neutral journalist means not caring who is right or wrong. 

To be an objective journalist – on the other hand — means not letting your personal biases affect you as you write about what is going on, or blind you as you seek the truth. 

It also means then presenting that truth in a fair and balanced manner.

So, this Black member of the media will not be staying neutral… can’t stay something I never was. 

But I will always strive to be objective. No one should expect me to be more.

  • Facebook
  • Twitter

Leave a Comment

Recent News


Feeling burnt out? Watch out for these symptoms

December 1, 2023

Tweet Email BPT If long workdays leave you wondering if you’re burnt out, take a closer look....

Food And Beverage

Hosting advice for a perfect holiday ham

December 1, 2023

Tweet Email FAMILY FEATURES Bringing together loved ones with classic seasonal meals is a staple of the...


‘Conversations For Sistas Only’ conveys the deep thoughts of today’s Black woman

December 1, 2023

Tweet Email By Napoleon F. Kingcade ABOVE PHOTO: Director/producer Frankie Darcell and the cast of “Conversations for...


Former Pro Bowl wide receiver DeSean Jackson to retire as an Eagle

November 29, 2023

Tweet Email ABOVE PHOTO:  DeSean Jackson  (AP Photo/Matt Rourke ) From 6abc: PHILADELPHIA (WPVI) — Wide receiver DeSean...

Fur Babies Rule!

Shared meal experiences: The next big thing bringing people and pups closer

December 1, 2023

Tweet Email BPT Do you throw birthday parties for your dog? Include them in family photos? Maybe...


Prepare your bathroom for holiday guests with 7 simple upgrades

December 1, 2023

Tweet Email BPT  If you’re hosting guests this holiday season, there’s much to do to prepare. Decorating,...

The Philadelphia Sunday Sun Staff