7:50 PM / Thursday January 26, 2023

2 Nov 2018

A Bit of Political Minstrelsy

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
November 2, 2018 Category: Commentary Posted by:

ABOVE PHOTO:  Diamond and Silk  (Photo: YouTube screen grab)


Or, what I observed sitting through the Diamond and Silk Show.


By Denise Clay

Most of the time when I cover political events, all that’s needed for me to get in is my name and an RSVP to the person handling communications for said event.

But when I went to a campaign event for Scott Wagner, the Republican vying to become Pennsylvania’s governor, I needed a state issued ID. That is until they found out that I was a member of the press. Suddenly, folks backed off from that.

(Having a Secret Service credential from a National Convention tends to do that.)

Last Friday night, I found myself at the Hilton City Line at Wagner’s event featuring Diamond and Silk, the two Black women who made a name for themselves in the 2016 Presidential campaign by being Donald Trump’s biggest Black fans. The first time that I saw them up close was during the Republican National Convention in Cleveland, where they decided to have a debate with newsman Roland Martin.

(Go on YouTube and punch in “Roland Martin+Diamond and Silk”. You won’t be disappointed.)

The sisters, Lynette Hardaway and Rochelle Richardson, were there as part of an event that I can only surmise was designed to bring Black folks into the Republican camp. I mean, it also featured Tracy Fisher, an ex-offender and Democrat who said he’s voting for Wagner because he believes that Republicans will be better for the community.

But if that’s what anyone got out of that, they’re better than me.

What I got was a chance to see was (a) what “fill-in-the-blanks” political campaigning looks like and (b) just how much of the soul of two women $25,000 can buy.

To fully get the Diamond and Silk experience, you have to start by imagining what it would look like if Madea, the pistol-packing church mother that actor/director/writer of really bad scripts Tyler Perry announced that he was shutting down this week, had an equally outrageous twin sister with whom she went on political tours.

And even then, you might not get the full picture.

First of all, most of the performance from the South Carolina natives had nothing to do with Pennsylvania. With the exception of eventually getting the crowd to chant “Tom Wolf Is A Wolf In Sheep’s Clothing”, much of what Diamond and Silk said was the same kind of red meat that Republicans get thrown nationwide.

From sanctuary cities, to the caravan heading north from Honduras due to American foreign policy (oops that’s me putting some context to what they said), to two of the Republican Party’s two favorite bogeymen, California Congresswomen Nancy Pelosi and Maxine Waters, and just about every other lie that Trump has been telling since he came down from his Trump Tower apartment in 2015, Diamond and Silk didn’t give anyone any reason to vote for Scott Wagner.

As they did a question and answer bit with Wagner after their initial performance, you could tell that they didn’t know a whole lot about him, what he stood for, or any of the issues he would face should he become governor of Pennsylvania. It was as if they were paid to be there.

That’s because they were. Twenty-five thousand dollars to be exact, according to a campaign finance filing from the Wagner campaign.

But while the less-than-dynamic duo didn’t really give Wagner the boost that he paid for, they did give the mostly White audience the kind of performance that made them feel comfortable because it was the kind of Blackness that they could relate to. The kind of Blackness that’s non-threatening. The kind of Blackness that doesn’t challenge them. The kind of Blackness that would make Megyn Kelly smile.

The kind of Blackness that buys into just about every stereotype of pre-Civil Rights Movement Blackness you can come up with.

Their neck rolling was the kind of stuff that might get them one step closer to getting that move declared an Olympic sport. There was also the kind of eye bugging you might see on an episode of “Amos and Andy” or “The Little Rascals”. There was a sing-song delivery that featured a lot of sound effects.

It was kinda painful to watch.

Especially since the audience lapped it up and laughed it up.

If you’re a Black person who is conscious about the images of Black folks, watching Diamond and Silk come close to blackface in the name of political minstrelsy will disgust you and want them thrown off the stage. Especially since it seems as if they know that this is what’s going on and continue to do it anyway.

Until Friday night, I didn’t realize that the going rate for two souls was $25,000, but apparently, it is.

For Diamond and Silk, I hope it’s worth it.

Personally, I like my dignity a lot more.

  • Facebook
  • Twitter

Leave a Comment

Recent News


Shapiro takes oath of office to become 48th Pa. governor

January 20, 2023

Tweet Share Pin Email ABOVE PHOTO: Democratic Gov. Josh Shapiro speaks after taking the oath of office...

Sun Report

January is Human Trafficking Prevention Month

January 20, 2023

Tweet Share Pin Email By Emily Walter,  Office of Domestic Violence Strategies, Mayor’s Office of Engagement for...


SUNrise: cj speaks…  Talents and gifts

January 20, 2023

Tweet Share Pin Email One of my favorite spaces to go to show my talents and gifts...


Caring for Older Adults:  Managing heart attack treatment and follow-up care

January 20, 2023

Tweet Share Pin Email FAMILY FEATURES As the proportion of older adults in the U.S. continues to...


A side-by-side look at the Trump, Biden classified documents

January 20, 2023

Tweet Share Pin Email ABOVE PHOTO: The letter from House Oversight Committee chairman Rep. James Comer, R-Ky.,...

Food And Beverage

Top five cooking trends for 2023 to check out

January 20, 2023

Tweet Share Pin Email BPT If you love exploring ingredients and new ways to cook old favorites,...

The Philadelphia Sunday Sun Staff