Mandela family got free legal aid meant for poor, Law Clinic says
ABOVE PHOTO: Mandla Mandela, right, grandson of former president Nelson Mandela, and his mother Nolusapho Mandela, left, at a news conference in Mvezo, South Africa, Thursday, July 4, 2013.
By Wandoo Makurdi and Christopher Torchia
JOHANNESBURG — Nelson Mandela’s family has come under new scrutiny after a South African university law clinic said it gave free legal aid to a group of the former president’s relatives on the grounds that some are poor.
The revelation was met with skepticism in South Africa where poverty is endemic and a number of commentators have questioned whether a clinic that is supposed to help the needy was instead seeking benefits from association with the high-profile family.
Many South Africans were already troubled by the Mandela family feud, which has coincided with the long illness of the 95-year-old anti-apartheid leader. Mandela was taken to a hospital on June 8 to be treated for a lung infection; the government says he is improving but remains in critical condition.
Mandela’s family members went to court against a grandson of Mandela who exhumed the anti-apartheid leader’s three deceased children from Mandela’s hometown, Qunu, and reburied them in nearby Mvezo. The group won the case with help from the Rhodes University Law Clinic and the bodies were reburied in their original location.
The grandson, Mandla Mandela, is the oldest male Mandela heir and a tribal chief in Mvezo, where his grandfather was born.
Rhodes University said it became involved when the Mandela family urgently requested help from Wesley Hayes, a deputy director of the law clinic who was “previously known” to the family.
Among four family members deemed by the law clinic to be indigent and therefore deserving of aid are 22-year-old Mbuso and 20-year-old Andile, younger brothers of Mandla.
They were aligned in the case with a dozen other relatives including Mandela’s three surviving daughters, one of whom is South Africa’s ambassador in Argentina, and Graca Machel, Mandela’s wife and a former first lady of Mozambique.
Susan Smailes, director of the special projects for the university, said Wednesday that one objective of the clinic in taking the prominent case was to highlight the kind of issues that clinic lawyers are pursuing. In a statement on Monday, the university gave other reasons.
“It is not uncommon for law clinics to represent groups of people, including some who are not indigent, in litigation involving matters that impact on human rights and the socio-economic conditions of disadvantaged communities,” it said.
“The view was that Mr. Mandla Mandela’s approach to deciding this family matter was at the expense of women’s voices in the family,” it said. It noted “tension” between the role of women in traditional matters and women’s rights enshrined in South Africa’s constitution.
Freddy Pilusa, a spokesman for Mandla Mandela, said the dispute had nothing to do with women’s rights and that it was “absurd” to suggest that any member of the Mandela family is indigent.
“That is really tantamount to taking from the poor and giving to the rich,” Pilusa said in reference to the provision of legal aid to the family.
Hayes, a salaried employee of the law clinic, did not receive additional payment for representing the family, according to Smailes. She said case costs would be covered by Mandla Mandela because he lost.
On its website, the law clinic says a key objective is to help those who can’t afford private lawyers, “thereby increasing access to justice to the poorest of the poor and creating a greater respect for the rule of law.”
+ Top Story
Most of Nelson Mandela’s handwriting is neat, but it harbors a few mysteries. Archivists sometimes struggle to decipher words in the vast body of documents that Mandela penned, and he often jotted an acronym that nobody, not even the former South African president in later years, has been able to explain.
Four investigations, hundreds of testimonies and stacks of medical reports on Yasser Arafat’s unexplained death in 2004 have failed to produce hard evidence of what killed him - and findings presented Friday only created more confusion.
Students from some of the toughest neighborhoods in Jamaica’s capital hunched over school desks, clacking wooden dominoes, pausing to ponder their next move and razzing opponents with good-natured taunts. “Look out, here comes the end of the game! Nobody can stop it,” said 20-year-old Chevon Brown.
Five African-American gentlemen in full 1860s-era Union troop regalia marched toward the west side of the Maury County Courthouse in Columbia. Two of them held the Tennessee and United States flags, a slight breeze brushing leaves past their feet as clouds covered the sky.
One of the world’s most wanted women, a British-born convert to Islamic extremism, lived close to one of Nairobi’s major malls in 2011 but likely wasn’t carrying out surveillance on it, a Kenyan security official said Wednesday.
In the aftermath of the worst terror attack in East Africa in three years, foreign policy scholars here are urging the U.S. government to rethink its counterterrorism policy in the region. Many are suggesting that the Somali Al Shabab militant organisation, reportedly linked to Al-Qaeda, may be stronger and...
Security forces and Islamist protesters clashed around the country Sunday, leaving 51 killed, as a national holiday celebrating the military turned to mayhem. Crowds from Egypt’s two rival camps — supporters of the ousted Islamist president, Mohammed Morsi, and backers of the military that deposed him...
The Sept. 21 terrorist attack on Nairobi’s Westgate Mall produced a raft of questions that haven’t always had clear, complete answers. The answers to some questions about the attack have changed over time. Other questions haven’t yet been fully answered.